Baseball Legends: What Would They Be Worth Now?

We all have favorite ball players from the past, with legends like Babe Ruth, Mickey Mantle and Lou Gehrig once coveted in every pack of baseball cards. But, as the game has changed over years, we wanted to know what the icons of yesteryear would be earning if they played pro ball now, and who would they play for?

At Digital Element, we deal with big data like audience insights and geolocation every day, so we wanted to put our data analysis skills to use in a way that people could relate to and enjoy. We’ve taken the statistics for twelve of the greatest baseball players of all time, comparing them like-for-like with modern day equivalents. Next, we analyzed the differences in performance to work out what the legends would be paid in today’s game and who they might play for.

The Method

To work out a direct comparison between players, we began by selecting twelve legendary names from the game of baseball and choosing twelve current MLB players who play in the same position and have been rated as some of the best in recent years. We then took the 162-game averages for each player and worked out the percentage difference between the two.

Taking the current salary of the 2020 player, we worked out the salary the legend would be paid for each statistic, taking the biggest rise as the amount they’d be paid – assuming the player would be paid a salary to match their greatest skill.

We also looked at the legend as if they were going to play for the same team as their modern-day equivalent, assuming they would have the finances to pay the amount.

The Players

Babe Ruth Vs. Mookie Betts

New York Yankees’ legendary right fielder Babe Ruth was first up at the plate. We chose to compare him to Mookie Betts of the Los Angeles Dodgers, and formerly of the Boston Red Sox. Betts won the Most Valuable Player, Silver Slugger, Gold Glove, batting title, and World Series in 2018, the first player to do so in the same season.

As for Ruth, he broke the single season MLB home run record in 1919 and was one of the first players inaugurated into the MLB Hall of Fame.

Babe Ruth Mookie Betts
Batting average 0.342 0.301
Runs 141 125
Hits 186 197
Home Runs 46 28
Runs Batted In 143 96
Strikeouts 86 95
Stolen Bases 8 26
SLG (Slugging Percentage) 0.690 0.519
Salary $44,357,143 $27,000,000

Babe Ruth 1930/31 Salary = $80,000

2020 Increase = $44,277,143

Based on Betts’ annual salary of $27 million, we’ve calculated that Babe Ruth would currently earn $44,357,143 if he were playing for Los Angeles Dodgers in 2020. This is based on the percentage difference on his strongest statistic – home runs.

Walter Johnson Vs Gerrit Cole

Having just made a big move to the New York Yankees for the 2020 season, Gerrit Cole is possibly regarded as the hottest pitching property in MLB. Cole was the 2019 MLB strikeout leader and has been a three-time all-star. Walter ‘The Big Train’ Johnson played his entire career as a Washington Senator and still holds the all-time record for shutouts at 110 – over 90 years since his last game. He was one of the first five players inducted into the Hall of Fame as is still regarded as one of the greatest pitchers the game has ever seen.

Walter Johnson Gerrit Cole
Games 802 192
Innings Pitched 274 212
Strikeouts 163 237
Wins 19 17
ERA (Earned Run Average) 2.17 3.22
WHIP 1.061 1.129
Salary $53,419,354 $36,000,000

 

Walter Johnson 1914 Salary = $17,500

2020 Increase = $53,401,854

Gerrit Cole just signed the biggest MLB contract for a pitcher at $38 million a year for the New York Yankees. If the Yankees were to sign Walter Johnson in the modern game, thanks to his superior earned run average of 2.17, they could expect to pay him $53,419,354 per season – that’s an increase of 305,153% on his 1914 salary.

Willie Mays Vs Mike Trout

‘The Say Hey Kid’ Willie Mays spent most of his career playing for the New York/San Francisco Giants, and is still one of only five players to have eight consecutive 100-RBI seasons. We’ve compared the great Willie to Mike Trout of the Los Angeles Angels. The New Jersey-born center fielder as of the end of 2019 was top of all major league players for career slugging percentage and on base plus slugging.

Last year, Mike Trout signed the highest-earning contract in MLB history for the Los Angeles Angels.

Willie Mays Mike Trout
Batting average 0.302 0.305
Runs 112 122
Hits 178 179
Home Runs 36 39
Runs Batted In 103 102
Strikeouts 83 151
Stolen Bases 18 27
SLG (Slugging Percentage) 0.557 0.581
Salary $33,575,980 $33,250,000

 

Willie Mays 1969/70 Salary = $135,000

2020 Increase = $33,440,980

Based on Mike Trout’s already record-breaking salary, and Willie Mays’ slightly superior record for runs batted in, we’re estimating that he’d be earning $33,575,980 if he were to sign for the Los Angeles Angels today.

Mickey Mantle Vs Freddie Freeman

New York Yankees first baseman Mickey Mantle, often referred to as the greatest switch hitter in the history of the game, won the Triple Crown for batting average, home runs and runs batted in during the 1956 season. Freddie Freeman of the Atlanta Braves, who is a four-season MLB All-Star player, won the Golden Glove Award in 2018, before taking the Silver Slugger Award in 2019.

The Mick is a Yankees legend, making it into the MLB team of the century in 1999 and the Hall of Fame in 1974.

Mickey Mantle Freddie Freeman
Games 2,401 1,346
Batting average 0.298 0.293
Runs 113 96
Hits 163 175
Home Runs 36 27
Runs Batted In 102 97
Strikeouts 115 141
Stolen Bases 10 5
SLG (Slugging Percentage) 0.557 0.504
Salary $24,000,000 $12,000,000

 

Mickey Mantle 1962 Salary = $90,000

2020 Increase = $23,910,000

Based on Mantle getting twice as many stolen bases (10 to 5) in his illustrious career, plus more runs, home runs and RBI, our statistics indicate that he’d be worth twice as much to the Atlanta Braves in the modern game.

Hank Aaron Vs Christian Yelich

Hammerin’ Hank Aaron played 21 seasons for the Milwaukee/Atlanta Braves, playing most of his games as a right fielder. He has three Golden Glove awards and was named MVP as the Braves won the 1957 World Series. Christian Yelich won a Gold Glove Award in 2014, the Silver Slugger Award in 2016 and 2018, and the National League’s Most Valuable Player Award in 2018.

Yelich currently plays outfielder for the Milwaukee Brewers, after being drafted from the Miami Marlins.

Hank Aaron Christian Yelich
Games 3,298 920
Batting average 0.305 0.301
Runs 107 103
Hits 185 188
Home Runs 37 24
Runs Batted In 113 88
Strikeouts 68 147
Stolen Bases 12 22
SLG (Slugging Percentage) 0.555 0.492
Salary $10,791,667 $7,000,000

 

Hank Aaron 1975/76 Salary = $240,000

2020 Increase = $10,551,667

If Hank Aaron were to turn out for the Milwaukee Brewers in 2020, our statistics show that a superior RBI, batting average and number of run would help him earn $10,791,667.

Ty Cobb Vs Cody Bellinger

Ty Cobb, ‘The Georgia Peach’, is one of the most successful players of all time and is credited with 90 different MLB records during his career, still holding the highest career batting average in MLB to this day. Cody Bellinger won the National League MVP award in 2019 and is the son of Clay Bellinger.

Currently playing for the Los Angeles Dodgers, Bellinger earns $11.5 million a year.

Ty Cobb Cody Bellinger
Games 3,034 450
Batting average 0.366 0.368
Runs 120 105
Hits 224 159
Home Runs 6 40
Runs Batted In 104 104
Strikeouts 36 146
Stolen Bases 48 14
SLG (Slugging Percentage) 0.512 0.559
Salary $39,428,571 $11,500,000

 

Ty Cobb 1921 Salary = $25,000

2020 Increase = $39,403,571

Considering Cobb’s illustrious career, it comes as no surprise that his salary would be much higher at the Los Angeles Dodgers in 2020. With a much higher number of stolen bases and hits, our research indicates that he’d be earning $39,428,571.

Cy Young Vs Justin Verlander

Eight-time all-star and Houston Astros pitcher, Justin Verlander is noted as one of the great pitchers in the modern game. A one-time World Series winner, member of the 3,000-strikeout club and 2011 Triple Crown winner, Verlander is one of the most decorated pitchers around in 2020. Despite ending his career over 100 years ago, Cy Young still holds the MLB record for most wins at 511 and won the 1903 World Series with Boston Americans.

Despite many years separating these two pitching giants, their shared influence on the art of pitching is undeniable.

Cy Young Justin Verlander
Games 906 453
Innings Pitched 291 224
Strikeouts 111 226
Wins 20 17
ERA (Earned Run Average) 2.63 3.33
WHIP 1.13 1.135
Salary $35,452,471 $28,000,000

 

Cy Young 1901 Salary = $3,000

2020 Increase = $35,449,471

Justin Verlander currently earns a salary of $28,000,000 per year for the Houston Astros. If the Astros were to sign Cy Young as part of their 2020 roster, he could expect to earn a cool $35,452,471 a year thanks to his superior earned run average.

Stan Musial Vs Miguel Cabrera

Stan ‘The Man’ Musial played for the St. Louis Cardinals and became the first ballot inductee to the Baseball Hall of Fame in 1969. With a career total of 6,134 bases, he’s only second to Hank Aaron, and he won three World Championships with the Cardinals. Detroit Tigers’ Miguel Cabrera has hit 30 or more runs in ten separate seasons and has the 33rd highest career slugging percentage of all time.

The Venezuelan first baseman is also an eleven-time All-Star player, whereas Musial has nine All-Star records.

Stan Musial Miguel Cabrera
Games 3,026 374
Batting average 0.331 0.244
Runs 104 88
Hits 194 116
Home Runs 25 32
Runs Batted In 104 84
Strikeouts 37 145
Stolen Bases 4 3
SLG (Slugging Percentage) 0.559 0.501
Salary $50,172,414 $30,000,000

 

Stan Musial 1957 Salary = $100,000

2020 Increase = $50,072,414

Musial’s illustrious career means that he has a higher 162-game average for runs, hits and RBI. Our analysis found that he’d be earning $50,172,414 if he were signed by Cabrera’s Detroit Tigers today.

Joe DiMaggio Vs Yoenis Céspedes

New York Yankee’s Joe DiMaggio was an All-Star in every one of his thirteen seasons and won the World Series nine times, making him the second-most decorated player in MLB history. Being compared to DiMaggio is a tough ask for any player, but Céspedes, a two-time All-Star, plus Golden Glove and Silver Slugger winner, holds his ground.

Despite never winning a World Series, Céspedes did appear in the 2015 game as a New York Met.

Joe DiMaggio Yoenis Céspedes
Games 1,736 826
Batting average 0.325 0.274
Runs 130 93
Hits 207 170
Home Runs 34 32
Runs Batted In 143 103
Strikeouts 34 143
Stolen Bases 3 8
SLG (Slugging Percentage) 0.579 0.498
Salary $40,537,634 $29,000,000

 

Joe DiMaggio 1950 Salary = $100,000

2020 Increase = $40,437,634

With DiMaggio proving himself as a born winner over the space of his thirteen-year career, it’s no shock that he would be paid much more if he were to turn out for the Yankees’ rival the New York Mets today, with a $40,537,634 annual salary.

Barry Bonds Vs Will Myers

Having played 22 seasons for the Pittsburgh Pirates and San Francisco Giants, Barry Bonds won 8 Golden Glove awards, 12 Silver Slugger and 7 NL MVP awards, amongst other accolades in his career. Will Myers of the San Diego Padres can’t quite match up to the number of awards won by Bonds in his career but does have a single All-Star appearance to his name.

Myers recently moved from baseman to outfielder for the Padres, meaning his stats have altered slightly.

Barry Bonds Will Myers
Games 2,986 785
Batting average 0.298 0.251
Runs 121 83
Hits 159 145
Home Runs 41 24
Runs Batted In 108 78
Strikeouts 83 173
Stolen Bases 28 19
SLG (Slugging Percentage) 0.607 0.436
Salary $38,437,500 $22,500,000

 

Barry Bonds 2005 Salary = $20,000,00

2020 Increase = $18,437,500

Bonds is one undisputed legend of the game, meaning his runs, hits, home runs, RBI and stolen bases are all higher than Myers’. For that reason, our statistics show that he’d be earning $38,437,500 at the San Diego Padres in 2020.

Lou Gehrig Vs Albert Pujols

Lou Gehrig, known as ‘The Iron Horse’ for his hitting prowess, is one of the New York Yankees’ greatest first basemen. The six-time World Series winner and Hall of Fame member won two AL MVP awards, as well as the AL Batting Champion and Triple Crown in 1934. Albert Pujols of the Los Angeles Angels, and previously St. Louis Cardinals, has won two World Series rings, as well as three NL MVP awards.

Pujols also has six Silver Slugger awards and two Golden Gloves to his name.

Lou Gehrig Albert Pujols
Games 2,986 2823
Batting average 0.298 0.3
Runs 141 105
Hits 204 184
Home Runs 37 38
Runs Batted In 149 119
Strikeouts 59 73
Stolen Bases 8 7
SLG (Slugging Percentage) 0.632 0.549
Salary $37,600,000 $28,000,000

 

Lou Gehrig 1939 Salary = $39,000

2020 Increase = $37,561,000

Lou Gehrig’s record of 141 runs over a 162-game average ensure him a salary of $37,600,000 in the 2020 Los Angeles Angels team. Gehrig also beats Pujols for hits, RBI, stolen bases and SLG.

Nolan Ryan Vs Steven Strasburg

‘The Ryan Express’ is a one-time World Series champion, and an eleven-time strikeout leader. Having played for the California Angels, Houston Astros and Texas Rangers, Nolan Ryan is one of only five pitchers inducted into the Baseball Hall of Fame. Steven Strasburg is currently pitcher at Washington Nationals, where he won the World Series in 2019.

Strasburg also has a World Series MVP and a Silver Slugger award to his name.

Nolan Ryan Steven Strasburg
Games 324 239
Innings Pitched 232 205
Strikeouts 246 241
Wins 14 16
ERA (Earned Run Average) 3.19 3.17
WHP 1.247 1.086
Salary $35,726,141 $35,000,000

 

Nolan Ryan 1980 Salary = $1,000,000

2020 Increase = $34,726,141

Maybe pitching is the one part of the game that hasn’t changed dramatically over the years, but our statistics indicate that, even if he were to turn out for the Washington Nationals in 2020, Nolan Ryan would only earn $726,141 more than Steven Strasburg.

Our analysis just shows how great some of the biggest legends in the history of baseball really were. Comparing them over the same average number of games highlights big differences in the performances of our legends compared to their modern-day equivalents. It also shows how, with the increase in salaries in MLB, these legends would have been paid huge amounts more money than they ever earned in their career.

Pricing Request

Digital Element pricing is based on two variables: data requested and estimated monthly volumes. Please contact us so that we can learn more about your specific needs.